As of May 2025, Rarity Bay real estate continues to thrive as one of eastern Tennessee’s premier gated communities, offering luxury lakefront and golf course living along the shores of Tellico Lake. Known for its breathtaking mountain views and resort-style amenities, Rarity Bay attracts homebuyers looking for a blend of elegance, security, and outdoor recreation. The market remains steady, with strong interest from retirees, second-home seekers, and active adults relocating for the area's peaceful setting and vibrant social lifestyle. Homes for sale in Rarity Bay range from stylish condos to expansive custom estates, all within easy reach of walking trails, a championship golf course, equestrian center, and private marina—making it an ideal choice for upscale lakeside living.
Median listing home price
Median listing home price/Sq ft
Median Days on Market
Rarity Bay offers a wide variety of homes to suit different lifestyles, including single-family homes, luxury estates, custom-built residences, and low-maintenance townhomes. Many properties are situated along the golf course or Tellico Lake, offering beautiful water or mountain views. Buyers can also find homes in gated sections or within walking distance to amenities like the clubhouse or marina.
The real estate market in Rarity Bay has remained strong, driven by demand from retirees, second-home buyers, and those seeking a relaxed lakefront lifestyle. Limited inventory and high buyer interest mean that desirable homes, especially those with premium views or upgraded features, tend to sell quickly. Home values have seen consistent growth, reflecting the community’s appeal and high quality of life.
Homes in Rarity Bay typically range from the low $400,000s to over $1.2 million, depending on location, size, and design. Lakefront homes and newer custom builds generally command higher prices, while smaller or interior-lot homes are more budget-friendly. Buyers can also purchase lots for custom construction, with prices varying based on location and view.
Rarity Bay is a master-planned community with distinct sections, each offering its own advantages. Homes near the golf course or lakefront areas tend to be the most sought-after, while some buyers prefer the privacy and tranquility of wooded or elevated lots. Properties near the clubhouse, tennis courts, or equestrian center are also popular for their proximity to amenities and social activities.
When purchasing a home in Rarity Bay, consider how the property aligns with your lifestyle goals—whether you prioritize lake access, golf, equestrian amenities, or a strong social scene. It’s important to understand the community’s HOA fees, club membership options, and any building restrictions if you plan to construct a custom home. Also, pay attention to the home’s orientation and elevation to make the most of the area’s scenic views.
To find a reliable real estate agent in Rarity Bay, TN, you can start by exploring online platforms. Additionally, you may consider reaching out to Eleanor Cippel a reputable real estate agent known for her proficiency in Rarity Bay real estate market. You can contact her directly for personalized assistance and guidance in your real estate endeavors.
Find Your Dream Rarity Bay Home for Sale
I'm totally committed to a better, more meaningful, collaborative and successful way to practice the great business of real estate! No matter your level of experience, you can take your business to the next level.